tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post5345686813540857193..comments2024-01-19T16:08:44.813+05:30Comments on SATYAM BRUYAT - Justice Katju : Ecrasez L’infame (Crush the infamy)Justice Markandey Katjuhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/00863856244827322851noreply@blogger.comBlogger10125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-16893954941300278002012-09-02T16:59:39.986+05:302012-09-02T16:59:39.986+05:30To Katju. J,
"nikala chaahta hai kaam kya ta...To Katju. J, <br />"nikala chaahta hai kaam kya taano se ai Ghalib,<br />tere be-mehr kehne se wo tujh par mehrbaan kyun ho"...Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17028048505074194192noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-41521889682318335012012-08-23T17:18:49.046+05:302012-08-23T17:18:49.046+05:30HONB'LE JUSTICE KATJU I humbly request you to ...HONB'LE JUSTICE KATJU I humbly request you to publish a source wherefrom you have taken a cue that the origional inhabitants of this land were ADIVASISAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-52651076472864843012012-08-23T13:00:25.737+05:302012-08-23T13:00:25.737+05:30Hon'ble Mr.Justice M.Katju:
I am in agreement...Hon'ble Mr.Justice M.Katju:<br /><br />I am in agreement with the concerns raised by your Lordship. Any citizen of India concerned about the national integrity and human rights would share Your Lordship's concerns. I apprehend, politricks (alas! we do not have politicians worth the name in India now, like the one we had about 2300 years ago--Chanakya) behind such incidents that happened to the people in NE parts of India. True, the people from North Eastern parts of India are a neglected lot. It is for the policy makers in Delhi to realize that consolidation and not confrontation is only means to keep this country united and strong.<br /><br />With respectful regards,<br />Yours faithfully,<br /><br />Adv.Anilkumar Kappillil<br />Advoate, High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, Cochin.YAJNAVALKYAN CHIRIKKUNNUhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04555346714123654867noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-12770279695591364192012-08-18T07:28:24.551+05:302012-08-18T07:28:24.551+05:30I broadly agree with what you wrote, but it appeal...I broadly agree with what you wrote, but it appeals to less than 5% of our population.<br />In the light of what is happening, what is needed is more police force, more investment in providing needed equipment, and more intelligence gathering. Also efficient and faster justice system. <br />Mannnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-4101265916882561442012-08-18T05:03:25.578+05:302012-08-18T05:03:25.578+05:30Don't agree at all!Your blog does not speak ab...Don't agree at all!Your blog does not speak about the real issue- about Bangladeshi migrants encroaching on Bodo land and wavers into issue of Maharashtra which has no relevance.The opinion expressed about issue of Maharashtra is one sided and without unbiased study of real study of the issue and the underlying problem.By your logic, we all should allow Bangladeshi people everywhere in India and provide them with full rights as Indians since Bangladesh was part of India one time and our so called secular leaders allowed everyone to decide where to stay!Anything man made including constitution is error prone and needs amended.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-73194120826982770842012-08-18T00:32:45.565+05:302012-08-18T00:32:45.565+05:30I wish Indian government could utilize you in some...I wish Indian government could utilize you in some better way than just making a toothless chief of PCI!Mayankhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13217201659279406852noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-75381460008908689622012-08-17T23:09:02.838+05:302012-08-17T23:09:02.838+05:30Justice Katju, I so agree with this post, like mos...Justice Katju, I so agree with this post, like most of your other posts. I can personally find connection to this post more than others because, I've experienced it personally. My mother-tongue is Tamil. I was born & raised in Maharashtra. My great grand parents migrated from T.N. to Karnataka. Currently my family resides in Bangalore and from the past 4yeas, I live in the US. I don't know what exactly is my native land. But calling myself an Indian seems to make it easy for me. <br /><br />I wish the sensible people of India understand this diversity and act accordingly.Vijay Nadadurhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02235226168162028794noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-43259833483165786612012-08-17T22:26:26.107+05:302012-08-17T22:26:26.107+05:30Though I broadly agree with rationale of treating ...Though I broadly agree with rationale of treating every Indian equally and protecting them under constitutional laws, I think (with sizeable knowledge that I possess) it would be slightly over-board to say 93% of Indians are immigrants and India is like US in this respect. Firstly, the Aryan-Dravidian theory is highly debated one, with some scholars now believing they are one and same civilization. Secondly, Indus Valley Civilization was indeed a native, highly developed and tolerant society. To call them outsiders would be unfair; if only Bhils are real inhabitants, why should we not go further and also consider them outsider (considering tectonic plates and homo-erectus). Thirdly, that India is diverse could also be explained by foreign invaders and their influence on local inhabitants, rather than foreign settlements as was the case in US. Though there is lot of diversity in India, most of them could be assembled in one common genetic group, which makes one doubt on "all-outsiders" theory.LieXhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04622975681980869174noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-66527990749273853832012-08-17T22:23:10.468+05:302012-08-17T22:23:10.468+05:30Though I broadly agree with rationale of treating ...Though I broadly agree with rationale of treating every Indian equally and protecting them under constitutional laws, I think (with sizeable knowledge that I possess) it would be slightly over-board to say 93% of Indians are immigrants and India is like US in this respect. Firstly, the Aryan-Dravidian theory is highly debated one, with some scholars now believing they are one and same civilization. Secondly, Indus Valley Civilization was indeed a native, highly developed and tolerant society. To call them outsiders would be unfair; if only Bhils are real inhabitants, why should we not go further and also consider them outsider (considering tectonic plates and homo-erectus). Thirdly, that India is diverse could also be explained by foreign invaders and their influence on local inhabitants, rather than foreign settlements as was the case in US. Though there is lot of diversity in India, most of them could be assembled in one common genetic group, which makes one doubt on "all-outsiders" theory.LieXhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04622975681980869174noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-3198541167297507132012-08-17T18:30:10.211+05:302012-08-17T18:30:10.211+05:30In full agreement Sir. While the constitution says...In full agreement Sir. While the constitution says many good things but its implementatio is as farce as a mirage. Had the Indian govt been homogenous in its approach in dealing with such situations irrespetive of who is the perpetrator & what religion he belongs to, this issue wouldn't have got beyond the hands, in fact none would. At one hand we want to go Global however mentality always has been that of a regionalist. For 2 mins, even I were to believe that Bhumiputra theory is correct & Maharashtra belongs to the incumbent Marathis, where does the Indian culture teach to throw one out who has visited your house? Had such creatures been dealth sternly, it would have sent a message - magar yeh ho na saka - so eventually we are selective & we always would - India would keep dis-integrating like this unless someone like Chanakya.....Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07178026845356403030noreply@blogger.com