tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post5537375364085640940..comments2024-01-19T16:08:44.813+05:30Comments on SATYAM BRUYAT - Justice Katju : Zaibunnisa KaziJustice Markandey Katjuhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/00863856244827322851noreply@blogger.comBlogger36125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-39604265700014568312015-05-30T18:51:24.030+05:302015-05-30T18:51:24.030+05:30This comment has been removed by the author.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04730610595839888828noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-24813426477977656832013-04-12T14:45:36.301+05:302013-04-12T14:45:36.301+05:30सच्चाई यह है कि न्यायिक व्यवस्था और प्रणाली ...सच्चाई यह है कि न्यायिक व्यवस्था और प्रणाली से जुड़ा हर व्यक्ति, चाहे वह मामूली क्लर्क ही क्यों न हो, स्वयं को भीड़ से अलग एकदम खास समझता है । श्री काटजू तो सर्वोच्च न्यायालय के प्रधान न्यायाधीश रह चुके हैं अत: उनका यह व्यवहार हमें कतई अचंभित नहीं करता । उनके लिये मोडेस्टी और हंबलनेस जैसे शब्द कोई मायने नहीं रखते । abhiasha11https://www.blogger.com/profile/12926527417528707756noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-61761118971408782552013-04-01T13:42:26.227+05:302013-04-01T13:42:26.227+05:30MR.PPR I M READY FOR DEBATE ARE U........THE MY 4T...MR.PPR I M READY FOR DEBATE ARE U........THE MY 4TH LINE OF PREVIOUS BLOG SAYS SOCIAL INTEREST NOT ONLY FOR SD BUT EVEN TO SMALLEST VILLAGE PEOPLE WHO EVEN DON''NT HAVE MONEY TO FIGHT THERE CASES.....I M NOT SAYING AND I M NOT SO INTELLLIGENT LIKE U SIR OR MR.JUSTICE KATJU....BUT I WROTE MY VIEWS WITH GROUND ZERO TRUTH......I BELONG TO BHARAT SIDE OF THIS NATION FRM SMALL VILLAGE IN REMOTE CORNERS OF UP.......BUT PLZ IT IS AND IT SHOULD BE FOR A END PEOPLE OF THIS COUNTRY ALSO....WE PEOPLE LIKE U AND JUSTICE KATJU...TO TRAVEL ACROSSS AND HELP THAT END PEOPLE.......I M ON MY STAND I DO NOT SUPPORT SD BUT THE SAME OPNION IN SD CASE MUST SEEN FOR END PEOPLE OF THIS COUNTRY ALSO WHO LIVES ON GROUND ZERO.....COME OUTSIDE OF INDIA.....AND PLZ SEE OUR BHARAT.............JAI HIND...SHAHILhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07993878592422715138noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-80354580494961075992013-03-30T14:29:43.201+05:302013-03-30T14:29:43.201+05:30So now to save Sanjay Dutt, you are pardoning anot...So now to save Sanjay Dutt, you are pardoning another terrorist. One wrong to support another wrong. <br />From your definition Sanjay wasn't a terrorist, but this other lady has been convicted under TADA. Atleast have some shame now !! <br />So what if she is 70 now, when the crime was committed she was 50 and aware of what she was doing.<br />Going by your logic, anyone who is 50 can commit any terror activity, coz court cases take decades and nobody should be punished after so many years...Bhushanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09337821583652211435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-51238912659614620632013-03-30T11:09:23.536+05:302013-03-30T11:09:23.536+05:30It seems to be your strong supporter of terrorist ...It seems to be your strong supporter of terrorist organization from Pakistan. Because don’t forget this 1993 blast were planned by ISI chief and they took help of Dauood Ibrahim Kaskar. And Sanjay Dutt was close friend of Dauood Ibrahim. They met in Dubai and Sanjay gave his possible help for Mumbai Bomb Blast. These stories were known by every citizen of our country and you don’t know that it is more shocking and unbelievable. You are not only insulting my country but you are insulting Supreme Court and people of this country.<br />It is shameful that you were the Supreme court Judge. I would like to put question in front of you “why don’t you feel the pain of our countryman’s. Someone who lost their families “.<br />I lost my village friend in the 1993 Bomb Blast. If anybody kills your family member then only you will feel the real pain. <br />Please stop all Non- Sense. Country and Patriotism is more important than our law. Why we create law to protect the peoples not criminals. <br />Vitthal Khot <br />Vitthal Khothttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15605771941932027714noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-8032406162021346262013-03-29T10:13:46.740+05:302013-03-29T10:13:46.740+05:30I say 100% Indians are stupid and Hon'ble Just...I say 100% Indians are stupid and Hon'ble Justice is at the top of the tree among top 1%.<br /><br />- An Italian marineAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-40051812055010953192013-03-29T00:24:44.875+05:302013-03-29T00:24:44.875+05:30Ref inappropriate appeal for Pardon dtd 28/3/13,by... Ref inappropriate appeal for Pardon dtd 28/3/13,by Retd Justice Katju ignoring ammunition including 25 hand granades thrown on poors in Machhimar Jhoparpatti being recd by Sanjay Dutt(33 then and educated in best schools thus exposed to law reading regularly newspapers) in full active discussion as per enclosed confessions in<br />Dear Mr President/Mr Prime Minister/Mr Home Minister<br />Mostrespectfully ,I have to bring on record that 2 fit cases of life imprisonment has been benevolently turned into few years of detention by Hon'ble Supreme Court.In full knowledge of handgranades recorded as under by SC ,Justice Katju is belittling SC by saying Self-defence when Dutts already had 3 licences of weapons.<br />Begum Kaji receives ammunitions twice in 8 days,after checking the bag,both times being told that they will be used in Bombay blasts.Retracted statement when taken under TADA act with due procedure giving 48 hrs of time is still admissible.Justice Katju misleading President and PM by writing "a Prohibited weapon"while Sanjay Dutt kept handgranades which were later barbarically thown on SCHEDULED CASTES of Machhimar colony.If educated men of 34 years could not understand 25 handgranades brought by gangsters to Mumbai and accepts those on phone call by Annes Ibrahim Kaskar,brother of Dawwod,only J Katju can recommend him pardon to become political executive soon.<br />In case of Bugum Zaibunissa Anwar Kazi,who received handgranades etc with due checking by her twice in 8 days with full declaration of purpose of use in Bombay blasts,Life sentence is a fit case and CBI must be advised to file Curative petition for greater punishment to her.<br />J Katju is doing OB van politics like Arvind Kejriwal by taking only cases which will bring him media attention.Letters of mine citing relevant confessions recorded in SC Judgments is chosen to be ignored by J Katju.Which is similarly unfortunate as he rushed to appeal to Governor ,who does not have powers in Arms Act.Now writing to President and to feign his ignorance of law sending copies to PM and HM and not to Governor.On lighter note,J Katju is danger to employment of similar politician practicing appeasement like Digvijay Singh.<br />Letters written to J Katju follow with the request to dismiss him from salaried post for misleading President and PM by selective citations and causing instability in state by belittling SC sitting in salaried position and hurting sentiments of majority community thus demanding the impossible to cause rift between 2 communities.<br />high regards,<br />Navien Maxwell<br />28/3/13Maxwell Nhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09460420209464260406noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-72403360182228550662013-03-28T23:41:06.894+05:302013-03-28T23:41:06.894+05:30ये बात अब अच्छी तरह समझ में आती है की क्यूँ सांप्र...ये बात अब अच्छी तरह समझ में आती है की क्यूँ सांप्रदायिक, भ्रष्ट और सामंती शक्तियां और उनके अज्ञानी समर्थक जस्टिस काटजू का भरपूर और बात-बेबात पर विरोध करते हैं। ऐसा हमेशा हुआ है, इतिहास गवाह है। कम से कम उन आम देशवासियों को समझना चाहिए की कौन उनके पक्छ में है और कौन उनका इस्तेमाल कर रहा है, क्यूंकि बहुत अफ़सोस होता है जब आम जनता में से कुछ लोग सोशल मीडिया पर जस्टिस काटजू जैसे लोगों के बारे में भद्दी बातें लिखते हैं। देश को जस्टिस काटजू जैसे लोगों की बहुत ज़रुरत है पर ऐसे लोग "विलुप्त होती प्रजाति" के सामान बहुत कम रह गए हैं।Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-29390001237913314122013-03-28T21:42:29.201+05:302013-03-28T21:42:29.201+05:30Even bigger nuts are the media. Inviting this nut ...Even bigger nuts are the media. Inviting this nut to debates every day.<br /><br />@dnsh<br />Idiotic way of escaping logic by calling others idiots.PPRhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08665744057755480789noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-77264059697901097442013-03-28T21:38:31.466+05:302013-03-28T21:38:31.466+05:301. First give up your own illusion that you are so...1. First give up your own illusion that you are some intellectual (of 10% greats) and can understand rights and rules.<br /><br />2. Everyone is asking what is the social interest in granting pardon to SD or even the other lady. Do you have answer? In what manner SD will serve the society? By amassing more wealth? By producing more kids, as future sympathy earners?<br /><br />3. Before helping people understand rights ask Katju learn behavior first. He talks rudely in debates even with female panelists. On 27th March on CNN-IBN Rajdeep apologized to one Abha Singh for Katju rude behavior. <br /><br />THE WHOLE PICTURE--- did you even try to see THE WHOLE PICTURE before asking others? You will not rather you cannot. You understand only Sanjay Dutt and his rights. But not the impact on future cases.PPRhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08665744057755480789noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-27908288439054914172013-03-28T20:06:30.817+05:302013-03-28T20:06:30.817+05:30AGAIN I REPEAT THE SAME THING...............AND TO...AGAIN I REPEAT THE SAME THING...............AND TO EVERY ONE ALL ABOVE AUTHORS...WHY U THINK THAT U R NOT EQUAL TO A CELEBRITY...EVERYONE CAN FILE APPEAL FOR PARDON OF ACUSED IN SOCIAL INTEREST IF HE OR SHE REALLLY WANT TO SERVE FOR SOCIETY......IT IS VERY CORRECT THAT 90% OF INDIANS ACUTUALLY DON''NT EVEN KNOW THERE CONSITUTIONAL RIGHTS........PEOPLE LIKE JUSTICE KATJU ARE HEPLING PEOPLE TO KNOW THERE CONSITUTIONAL RIGHTS........SEE THE WHOLE PICTURE NEUTRALLY..MY FELLOW COUNTRY MEN....SEEE BHARAT.....ALSO NOT ONLY INDIA...........SHAHILhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07993878592422715138noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-4177998141545657702013-03-28T19:49:52.071+05:302013-03-28T19:49:52.071+05:30sir, one of the justice of your panel in S.C. said...sir, one of the justice of your panel in S.C. said that with increase in age crime does not decrease.my 83 yrs old grandmother,suffering from cancer and treated with a severe cancer operation on 14 sept.2001 and other ailments was not given any relief who was indirectly involved in a personal case under 498A and 304B but this 70 yrs old lady zabunissa kazi who was involved in a national level case of destruction along with sanjay dutt is offered with pardon even after being sentenced to jail for 5 yrs by the S.C. under TADA act who according to you cannot live for long which was similarly applicable for my grandmother.is not that inequality and against the constitution of India?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06850087141954115646noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-59591397576224236802013-03-28T18:41:09.777+05:302013-03-28T18:41:09.777+05:30Dear Katju ji,
In your previous blog you convicte...Dear Katju ji, <br />In your previous blog you convicted Narendra Modi-ji for 2002 riots even though there is no proof, no court has held him criminal. <br /><br />SIT monitored by SC has given him a clean-chit, due to a decade of witch-hunt against Modi-ji people have a wrong image of Modi-ji. Unfortunately you also accused him, that is not fair on your part.<br /><br />Going by your own ideology, please post a news article or a blog to pardon Modi-ji and ask other people also to pardon him. <br /><br />Why I think Modi-ji should be pardoned by secular media and ex-congress people like yourself - <br />1. He is not held guilty by any law in India<br />2. He has suffered a lot in these 10 years, he couldn't go to US/Europe<br />3. His carrier went down and he had to work hard to revive it<br />4. He spread message of shri Vivekananda and shri Vallabh Bhai Patel<br />5. There are lot of eminent lawyers, cricketers, film stars, business men who support him<br />6. His way of repenting is a bit different, you can observe that there is not a single incident of communal violence after 2002, even though Gujarat always was a communally sensitive state.Bhushanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/09337821583652211435noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-49043836596944179172013-03-28T18:36:53.773+05:302013-03-28T18:36:53.773+05:30Sir,
After reading your profile in Wikipedia, I wa...Sir,<br />After reading your profile in Wikipedia, I was impressed that you come from such a distinguished family and have served the judiciary for so many years; and now you are serving the country as the Chief of the Press Council of India.<br /><br />Granted that you've earned a right to speak in the media about matters concerning the dispense of justice, but don't you think you're falling in the same trap of showing benevolence where you should be upholding the reputation of the highest court of our country of which you also were a part?<br /><br />Just as "trial by media" is looked down upon by the government, speaking against the judgement of the Supreme Court is an attempt to weaken its reputation in the eyes of the public by speaking directly to the media. In fact, this brings disrepute to the entire judiciary process of which you, of all the people, are well aware.<br /><br />To the rest of India, your opinions have carried weight. But by carelessly, and for reasons best known to you, mouthing quick comments about events that evoke no sympathy for convicts in the public eye; you are showing us that an air of elitism has entered your brain... and although you may not feel responsible for what you utter now as a "retired judge" and chalk it up to personal freedom of speech, it sadly throws your lot squarely with the rest of us 90% that you so disdainfully described as "stupid." If this continues, your march into oblivion will not be noticed. For your sake, and for the sake of our country, I hope and pray that saner heads prevail.<br /><br />Sincerely,<br />OneVoiceIndia<br />Pune, MaharashtraAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-26200676528665746402013-03-28T17:23:16.945+05:302013-03-28T17:23:16.945+05:30Dear sir
Why the proper route as enumerated under ...Dear sir<br />Why the proper route as enumerated under sec.432, 433 and 433A of the criminal procedure code is adopted for getting commutation of sentence for sanjay and others. As sanjay himself has said that there are several other convicts who are in real need of pardon. Will it not be proper that the appropriate govt move the session court for its opinion with detailed chart of all deserving convicts depicting period actually served in jail, behaviour inside the jail, conduct outside the jail if he/she has been on bail. Then the govt may implement the opinion of the session court which in the eyes of public will command more respect rather than short circuiting the whole process and approach governor for pardon on selective basis.Anand Mohanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03684053264992069473noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-65045331236346334032013-03-28T17:20:27.177+05:302013-03-28T17:20:27.177+05:30Justice Katju sir if you are really in top 1% of t...Justice Katju sir if you are really in top 1% of the 99% stupid people in India then rebut my following argument:<br /><br />chota bachcha jaan ke na koyi aankh dikhaana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />akal ka kachcha samajhake na hamako samajhana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />bholi surat jaan ke hamase na takraana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />na dhin dhinna na dhin dhinna naach nacha denge<br /><br />ik din deke do athaniya maa boli ja le aa dhaniya - (2)<br />paise deke dukaandaar se main bola baabu de do dhaniya<br />bada taraaju lekar usane rakh diya usamein thoda sa dhaniya<br />maine bola babu baniya, kaagaj bech rahein ya dhaniya<br />kaagaj rakho baaju mein, dhaniyein ko rakho taraaju mein<br />sun meri baat woh raha na kaabu mein, kya bola<br />bola tujhako bataau main, main bhi kahaan kam tha<br />maine bhi keh diya bachche thakata hai, shor machaau main<br />usake baad huwa kya yeh bhi batalaana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />usake baad -2 toh usaka jaise mar gaya naana re<br />bich bajariya gaaya maine jab yeh gaana re<br />chota bachcha jaan ke na koyi aankh dikhaana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />akal ka kachcha samajhake na hamako samajhana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taapAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-15825768111172469812013-03-28T17:19:16.297+05:302013-03-28T17:19:16.297+05:30Justice Katju sir if you are really in top 1% of t...Justice Katju sir if you are really in top 1% of the 99% stupid people in India then rebut my following argument:<br /><br />chota bachcha jaan ke na koyi aankh dikhaana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />akal ka kachcha samajhake na hamako samajhana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />bholi surat jaan ke hamase na takraana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />na dhin dhinna na dhin dhinna naach nacha denge<br /><br />ik din deke do athaniya maa boli ja le aa dhaniya - (2)<br />paise deke dukaandaar se main bola baabu de do dhaniya<br />bada taraaju lekar usane rakh diya usamein thoda sa dhaniya<br />maine bola babu baniya, kaagaj bech rahein ya dhaniya<br />kaagaj rakho baaju mein, dhaniyein ko rakho taraaju mein<br />sun meri baat woh raha na kaabu mein, kya bola<br />bola tujhako bataau main, main bhi kahaan kam tha<br />maine bhi keh diya bachche thakata hai, shor machaau main<br />usake baad huwa kya yeh bhi batalaana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />usake baad -2 toh usaka jaise mar gaya naana re<br />bich bajariya gaaya maine jab yeh gaana re<br />chota bachcha jaan ke na koyi aankh dikhaana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taap<br />akal ka kachcha samajhake na hamako samajhana re<br />tupi tupi taap taap, tupi tupi taap taapAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-67748630781402674162013-03-28T15:33:52.414+05:302013-03-28T15:33:52.414+05:30Dear Mr Katju,
There are many innocents languishin...Dear Mr Katju,<br />There are many innocents languishing in indian jails, as they could not afford to fight for long and many for for their ignorance or innocence or bad luck. Why dont you fight for them, rather than fighting for someone who himself wants to serve the punishment, as he knows he is guilty. You can start one NGO to help such innocents, if you really believe in what you re claiming to be. <br /><br /><br /><br />Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08154560229064474275noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-12677784841509250482013-03-28T15:13:58.125+05:302013-03-28T15:13:58.125+05:30good one, salman, u surely deserve pardon. once ou...good one, salman, u surely deserve pardon. once our judge is free from serving our politicians, he will take up your pardon case.Money from Stockshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05893733017374216759noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-21698264425231614832013-03-28T15:11:29.008+05:302013-03-28T15:11:29.008+05:30Katju is a nut, an old man with no senses and only...Katju is a nut, an old man with no senses and only seeking cheap publicity. He needs to be always in news, thats why he writes or talks of sensational cases. Good he has retired. I dont know how he got to supreme court. may eb like what abhishek singhvi did :)Money from Stockshttps://www.blogger.com/profile/05893733017374216759noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-16861229411829523042013-03-28T15:04:47.613+05:302013-03-28T15:04:47.613+05:30Mr. Katju
You are one of the dirtiest persons I ha...Mr. Katju<br />You are one of the dirtiest persons I have ever heard about. You are uncouth. My friends say that you are stupid. But you may not be that. You are actually one of those who like to subvert justice and I think that must have been the express reason that you became a judge. You are terribly conceited as came out from your utterances on a TV debate. You are egotist, an egomaniac. For you 99% indians are stupid. Well I am one of those 99% and feel thankful that I do not belong to your 1%.Avinash Upadhyayhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14153286517295696042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-88773391270836160412013-03-28T14:59:02.661+05:302013-03-28T14:59:02.661+05:30This comment has been removed by the author.Avinash Upadhyayhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14153286517295696042noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-65155871617672146022013-03-28T14:17:20.805+05:302013-03-28T14:17:20.805+05:30I heard Mr KAtju's debate in TIMES NOW with Mr...I heard Mr KAtju's debate in TIMES NOW with Mr Swami where in he says "I Know Law better than any one else and more than Swami " Which shows how a person like Katju's can stoop to such a level to get his views thrust on other in a debate...He should first meet Mr V.R Krishnaiyer and learn modesty and humbleness...! HE is getting better than Digvijay Singh these days...!!Kannanhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/16217492677736970033noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-14025374189558404822013-03-28T13:42:03.433+05:302013-03-28T13:42:03.433+05:30Sanjay dutt deserves huge applaud. He upheld Hindu...Sanjay dutt deserves huge applaud. He upheld Hindu principles in true sense. He understood that one SHOULD not escape punishment for own sins. It is misfortune of this country. A convict knows Dharma better than Guardians of Justice. SD gave a slap on the publicity mongers in the name of pardon. I pray this slap awakens them to reality.PPRhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08665744057755480789noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-30400658911456244532013-03-28T13:40:49.670+05:302013-03-28T13:40:49.670+05:30You are criminally insane Mr Katju.Only in a, medi...You are criminally insane Mr Katju.Only in a, mediocre, sick and a perverted country like our India, can such creatures acquire the high positions that they do! No wonder the rest of the world treats us with the contempt we deserve!Ravi Patelhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/01605264183556152904noreply@blogger.com