tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post7097422379243163166..comments2024-01-19T16:08:44.813+05:30Comments on SATYAM BRUYAT - Justice Katju : Corruption in JudiciaryJustice Markandey Katjuhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/00863856244827322851noreply@blogger.comBlogger47125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-2389216898145910352015-10-25T15:25:56.411+05:302015-10-25T15:25:56.411+05:30High court of Gujarat has filled suo moto contempt...High court of Gujarat has filled suo moto contempt of court proceedings against me. saying that u have done baseless allegation of corruption against the judicial office a d achariya. High court of Gujarat has fill fir against the same judge and others at Vigilance's polish station at high court of Gujarat. U/s of IPC and preventions of corruption act. Now high court has withdraw the suo moto contempt of court proceedings against me. And said than there are no baseless allegation made by u. So now it as clear that my complaint was true. So fir should lonch against the accused. Help me what should I do suggestion of your all how fight against the corruption.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02424229098799277266noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-1760893462753762552015-10-25T15:25:46.827+05:302015-10-25T15:25:46.827+05:30Honourable justice kayju kindly suggest what shoul...Honourable justice kayju kindly suggest what should I doAnonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02424229098799277266noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-82029150105195704782015-10-25T15:20:32.946+05:302015-10-25T15:20:32.946+05:30Honourable justice kayju kindly suggest what shoul...Honourable justice kayju kindly suggest what should I doAnonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02424229098799277266noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-33166963230606864112015-10-25T15:11:49.827+05:302015-10-25T15:11:49.827+05:30High court of Gujarat has filled suo moto contempt...High court of Gujarat has filled suo moto contempt of court proceedings against me. saying that u have done baseless allegation of corruption against the judicial office a d achariya. High court of Gujarat has fill fir against the same judge and others at Vigilance's polish station at high court of Gujarat. U/s of IPC and preventions of corruption act. Now high court has withdraw the suo moto contempt of court proceedings against me. And said than there are no baseless allegation made by u. So now it as clear that my complaint was true. So fir should lonch against the accused. Help me what should I do suggestion of your all how fight against the corruption.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02424229098799277266noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-67917418505183631532015-10-25T15:11:48.540+05:302015-10-25T15:11:48.540+05:30High court of Gujarat has filled suo moto contempt...High court of Gujarat has filled suo moto contempt of court proceedings against me. saying that u have done baseless allegation of corruption against the judicial office a d achariya. High court of Gujarat has fill fir against the same judge and others at Vigilance's polish station at high court of Gujarat. U/s of IPC and preventions of corruption act. Now high court has withdraw the suo moto contempt of court proceedings against me. And said than there are no baseless allegation made by u. So now it as clear that my complaint was true. So fir should lonch against the accused. Help me what should I do suggestion of your all how fight against the corruption.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02424229098799277266noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-45881749637108726192015-10-20T14:37:28.373+05:302015-10-20T14:37:28.373+05:30One magistrate did not obey the order of the Hon&#...One magistrate did not obey the order of the Hon'ble High Court.<br />When I filed contempt petition in Hon'ble High Court, my petition was dismissed stating that it was not maintainable by misinterpreting Sections in Cr.PC.<br /><br />Kindly suggest what I have to do.<br />Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06120872210359815827noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-83380441850344199082015-06-05T01:40:54.582+05:302015-06-05T01:40:54.582+05:30Honorable Justice Katju,
No comission or forum can...Honorable Justice Katju,<br />No comission or forum can help discourage corruption as long as there is no constitutional provision to punish the corrupt judges. If even after impeachment, judges can continue to receive their salaries and retain benefits what would discourage them from being corrupt? There are quite a few cases where judges are being appointed merely due to their political affilitiation some times as a quid-pro-quo to a favor done by them to a political leader while they were in subordinate judiciary.<br />Why can't they be tried in public television and shamed in public?. As an example I recall the kind of questions Bill Clinton had to face when he was impeached. Some of the questions were denigrating and would appear to belittle a sitting president. I am sure Clinton was taught a lesson. <br />Also the impeachment / trial must be done by an independent eminent jurist and not by legislative members or other members of judiciary. Chief Justice's role should be limited to presiding role. No interference from him should be tolerated. <br />With all due respects, the founding fathers of the constitution didn't anticipate that the quality of legislative members and vis-a-vis the quality of judiciary would deteriorate over time and that was a grave blunder they committed. Modern white collar crimes require modern progressive thoughts.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13063080370107878833noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-11102224264141213012015-05-19T15:32:16.182+05:302015-05-19T15:32:16.182+05:30Sir my family is also victim of corrupt and fragil...Sir my family is also victim of corrupt and fragile judicial system. system ruined us completely. All fact with us bt no one argue on law point. Losseing faith from indian judicial sysytem. Its better to leave this country. varun2210https://www.blogger.com/profile/18087376141168165964noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-31200649576257851592015-05-19T15:31:20.676+05:302015-05-19T15:31:20.676+05:30This comment has been removed by the author.varun2210https://www.blogger.com/profile/18087376141168165964noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-47106883450126672742015-05-19T15:30:23.652+05:302015-05-19T15:30:23.652+05:30Sir my family is also victim of this corrupt and f...Sir my family is also victim of this corrupt and fragile judicial system. It completely ruined us. No one argue law points and all admitted facts are ignored. Its better to leave this country. varun2210https://www.blogger.com/profile/18087376141168165964noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-64973541318019799442015-05-19T15:29:05.195+05:302015-05-19T15:29:05.195+05:30Sir my family is also victim of this corrupt and f...Sir my family is also victim of this corrupt and fragile judicial system. It completely ruined us. No one argue law points and all admitted facts are ignored. Its better to leave this country. varun2210https://www.blogger.com/profile/18087376141168165964noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-37814100875859423372015-02-13T22:05:43.404+05:302015-02-13T22:05:43.404+05:30hats off! but we will also like to hear a solution...hats off! but we will also like to hear a solution from u on dis corruption issue!manuhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/15756161580845652886noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-22806308609271840152014-08-24T20:32:37.800+05:302014-08-24T20:32:37.800+05:30Steve I am not regular user of blog/facebook and w...Steve I am not regular user of blog/facebook and want that the question if feel that can be answerable by you for the social cause then please reply via the mail stgp74@gmail.com and me be contacted at 9810304299.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03020586293455363531noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-65225258031426390642014-08-24T20:28:26.995+05:302014-08-24T20:28:26.995+05:30Steve its my first time to write to you. I am not ...Steve its my first time to write to you. I am not concerned who is write or wrong in the discussion. What Mr. Katju has brought to notice seems preety good as he has brought the corrupt practices in the judiciary but the timing he made the shot is suspected, if he knew about it earlier. <br /> What about I am bothered is that whether the Indian Judiciary is going to improve or will deteriorate after the implementation of the new Judiciary bill 2014. After all judges are also people and how some of a few among them can't be corrupt? Are the politicians not corrupt?<br /> Recently the Anti Corruption has awarded the Police No. Corrupt and MCD the No. 2. Are these going to be replaced due to this corruption or they are going to be overhauled? It is the fact that the justice delivery is detoriating day be day, and it is also a know fact to atleast me that the higher judiciary is not so much corrupt as it is been projected. Why to change the system when by rejuvenation the things can be improved.<br /> The CJI R M Lodha has stated that the collegium system has failed. So what does it mean? Can the CJI do anything if the Bill is passed and can stop the government be from doing this by the Supreme Court as it did when the UPA Government was passing the bill for favouring the criminalisation in the polictics? What will be better for the common man as whether the judiciary becomes more corrupt or the politician or the system, its only the common man who has to face the heat.What a common man can do in all this collegium and new judicial bill, where the common has to face the heat but he has not been asked that what he wants, whether he wants the existing Collegium to be repaired or wants that the new judicial bill to come in action? what will be the best for the common man? Is the Supreme Court so helpless at this stage that it is bound to follow the decision of the government? Is the government to powerful that it can implement the judiciary bill without the approval of the Supreme Court? If the Supreme Court is so helpless then will it be able to protect the common man in future? will the court will be able to be considered the custodian of the rights of the common man and the constitution? Are all the acts from the cancellation of the collegium till the implementation of the new Judicairy bill are going/will go following all the instruction as guided by the constitution? What were there with the common man to put his stand regarding the improvement/transparency in the collegium, though the common man efforts have not ever been seen in this regard in the past? What are at present means left with the common man in regard if he feels that the judiciary bill should not be implemented? Can a common man oppose the bill, if after its implementation he feels that the new bill has made the judiciary more worse than the collegium system? Will the criminals become more powerful or weak after the implementation of the new judicairy bill?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03020586293455363531noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-89329283391483453232014-08-20T21:02:22.767+05:302014-08-20T21:02:22.767+05:30The content in the following link may be useful in...The content in the following link may be useful in your case WP(C) 207 / 2014<br /><br />http://www.scribd.com/doc/235764174/Invalid-Andhra-Pradesh-Reorganisation-Act-2014 <br />Best regards.JPGLhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/17230362412188316416noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-57067641234065112452014-08-20T01:37:50.443+05:302014-08-20T01:37:50.443+05:30Sir, it is equally important to eradicate incompet...Sir, it is equally important to eradicate incompetent persons appointed as judges at all level right from Munsif Courts to High Courts. In fact, I deem incompetency is much worse factor than corruption. If you have chance please pay visit to lower courts at various Taluks, you will be astonished to find most of the Presiding Officers if not corrupt are lazy, untrained, imprudent and without basic knowledge of procedural law and practice function like a Lower Divisional Clerks. It is at this level of courts most of the litigant public suffers injustice and they do not have means to enter the arena of Higher Courts. The courts at grass root level have to be cleansed and systematized for better administration of judicial process. Appointing highly qualified, trained and competent persons with honour, honesty and dignity at lower courts is also more important. But like in any other Department of the Government Agencies, in Judiciary also we have allowed incompetent persons and corrupt persons to occupy at all level. paranhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00612753633372952800noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-54098795488507051642014-08-18T10:28:00.039+05:302014-08-18T10:28:00.039+05:30Dear Sir,
To make the Indian judicial system bett...Dear Sir, <br />To make the Indian judicial system better, one also needs to look at the provisions of the Advocates Act 1961 which needs thorough revisions to make it in line with the time and to ensure that the public offices created under the said Act are being managed with honesty, accountability, independence and transparency. Essentially, no operator can be regulator of his own conduct. This is not only against the principals of natural justice but such biasness also vitiates the independence, accountability, honesty and transparency in the system. <br /><br />We often read in newspapers that a member of Bar Council is alleged involved in the wrongdoing and arrested . But such members of Bar Councils have no duty, moral or otherwise, to maintain the standards expected from them while the Advocate Act was enacted in 1961 by our learned fore fathers. <br /><br />It is also understood that the complaint against the Advocates are being adjudicated in unfair, partial and biased manner as the office bearers elected by the Advocates are biased to adjudicate the complaints against the Advocates. You will not be surprised to know that nowadays the Bar Councils have become the centers of harassment, threat and extortion and some office bearer use their position to mint money. <br /><br />Notably, such conduct of the officer bearers of, and functionality of, the Bar Councils not only maligning the image of the profession of Advocate but it also acts as cancer to finish the faith of general public in the Indian legal system as Advocates are an essential part of the Indian legal system.<br />Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/16637118575683878181noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-10609619227137791362014-08-14T05:10:42.267+05:302014-08-14T05:10:42.267+05:30I would want respond from my end to your items lis...I would want respond from my end to your items listed from a) to h).<br /><br />a). Do we have a measure to define defame?. I don't think there any defaming of Judiciary. It can only strengthen Judiciary if more transparency and Video broadcasting of Court Sessions are allowed. Even China allows Video broadcasting of Court proceedings. The time has come, India can't procrastinate Video broadcasting of Court sessions, at the least the Trial Courts. <br />b). No way.<br />c). The Executive started corruption. Its was like Domino effect. It started with Emergency call, openly defying a Court Directive for personal gains disregarding the national purpose. Slowly other branches of Governments picked up momentum in Corruption. The 1984 Prevention of Corruption Act only promoted the Corruption openly, at least in Tamil Nadu its happening brazenly.<br />d). I support this.<br />e). The apathy of many showing frustration and blaming Mr. Katju, exposes the real social impatience, uncivilized and madness. Not good for India, if disregarded. <br />f). Well said.<br />g). I quote American Constitution's one beginning line....."in Order to make more perfect Union'.... You are absolutely right. <br />h). In other words, Democracy is always a Work in Progress. People should remember this. <br />~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~<br />My another observation: Indian leaders in UPA govt, failed to allocate ample for Foundations of a flourishing Union. Education, Judiciary and Law Enforcement. These foundations should have been improved tremendously prior to opening Indian economy to the world. Look at some fall outs. The 4 child who died in Car suffocation is due to lacking common sense in them. The car is a foreign car with Child Safety locks. Which means the Car can not be open from Inside, after the locks is set. My question to the society is this: Do we need the knowledge of Car first, or the Car first! MMS and PC thought let us first get the Car. And we learn the knowledge later. So, the nation is paying a huge price in many different safety violations, because the people of the nation is not equipped for modern India yet. Murthy S. Inquisitive Economisthttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00445173308747091977noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-68060467577933545512014-08-13T01:38:49.318+05:302014-08-13T01:38:49.318+05:30Mr Mathew, Self Cleaning-the process you suggest, ...Mr Mathew, Self Cleaning-the process you suggest, has not worked in Political Spectrum. It has not worked in Law Enforcement. It doesn't seem to have worked in Judiciary. It definitely has not worked in Parliament. One can't wait for 100 years for self-cleaning to work.! Do we need new Laws, or Constitutional Amendments or what? Murthy S. Inquisitive Economisthttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00445173308747091977noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-55796189332864559902014-08-12T18:49:35.489+05:302014-08-12T18:49:35.489+05:30The Pros and Cons of the above issue in my humble ...The Pros and Cons of the above issue in my humble opinion can be analysed as under,<br />a) Whether the disclosures made by Justice Katju are defaming and will defame the judiciary, the ultimate protector of our constitution and rule of law?<br />b) It is said that a man can control the whole world through his material resources but to control him we need a law which is above him and whether such revelations are going to undermine the authority of the judiciary?<br />c) The judiciary gains its Strength from the confidence of the people in the justice administration system. But presently everyone in the country are fed up with the present justice administration system which is highly time consuming, uncertain, whimsical and increasingly seen as corrupt by favouring corrupt. <br />d) Even the Honorable CJI when he took over, spoke about the need for 365 day working, discouraging unnecessary adjournments. He further canvassed and said that if good people are elevated as judges the entire problem can easily be addressed. This clearly shows that the present collegium system cannot be the only remedy for all the ills that are plaguing judiciary. <br />e) Justice Katju's statements in my humble opinion should be taken in the right spirit. A man of proven integrity and capability is making and revealing such information which is known to many. His views should not be written off and should be encouraged as it will surely cleanse the system.<br />f) Honorable Supreme Court, number of times said corruption is the cancer in the society, corruption is a human right violation as it bleeds poor and downtrodden. So what should a person suffering from cancer do? Should he put his disease under carpet? Or should he go to a doctor and get the surgery done?<br />g) No doubt no one is perfect, No system is full proof and No one is above law. We are in a dynamic world which calls for changes and that can be brought in only through revelations, discussions and finally on the basis of majority opinion. <br />h) In democracy it is the people's voice that is ultimate and superior. All the constitutional authorities are servants of the people. There can be no doubt about it. No one should consider that the present revelations are going to damage the confidence of people in judiciary, and indulge in criticising Mr. Katju. We should rally around Mr. Katju and strengthen his hands so that the will of the parliament in bringing the legislation in the judicial accountability is respected by one and all. <br />Finally no one should forget that India is the only working and successful democratic country and it is because of Honorable Supreme Court and the Brave, Honest, dedicated judges and every citizen of this great county will bow down for their services. But that should not prevent the change through discussions and deliberations which is the core of democracy. <br />CA V Venkata Sivakumar, FCA, LL.MAnonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00806166160179768023noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-64240336233347879952014-08-12T17:47:52.523+05:302014-08-12T17:47:52.523+05:30In a democratic system, checks and balances are es...In a democratic system, checks and balances are essential. But laws alone cannot ensure such a thing. If the head is rotten, the rot spreads too fast. So it is essential that the selection of constitutional authorities in a democracy is done with utmost care. It is better that the concerned authorities in Judiciary, executive and such other systems do the cleaning themselves, wisely at the appropriate time. Otherwise at some point of time they would be cleaned thoroughly that some new systems come to being. And that is the learning from history.Er. Rajan C Mathew FIEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/07271941784093385135noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-40583595910090358762014-08-12T13:27:27.122+05:302014-08-12T13:27:27.122+05:30Justice Katju deserves all the praise for the cour...Justice Katju deserves all the praise for the courage he has taken to speak what people, in any case, whisper. These kind of people are in short supply. Some people have raised the bogey of timing: by raising time issue, the point of argument is deflected and this is what the gentlemen are good at. May be somewhere they feel affected by the truth and suffer from cognitive dissonance. The argument is: can corruption colored justices deliver justice?. Why people can't take and tolerate others point of view? After all, this is the spine of democratic conversation. Discussion got to be debating the issue and not attacking the opponent: attack the argument and not Justice Katju and the timing. In fact, the very reasoning of timing, suffers from logical fallacy - " Argumentum Ad Hominem". Justice Katju please keep fighting; it is not defaming the judiciary. In fact, corrective measures would strengthen the institution and would bring fame only to it. There is no doubt, we have an A class judiciary institution and Justice Katju and many others are an example of it. By recognizing the bad spots and suggesting the corrective measures would add to the fame and not, by all means, it is a defame equivalent.Mahahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/10238787875311014551noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-62819909687041682332014-08-12T11:44:05.206+05:302014-08-12T11:44:05.206+05:30Mr. Vishnu Alluri:
It seems to me that you have n...Mr. Vishnu Alluri:<br /><br />It seems to me that you have never been to a court in India in your lifetime till now! Otherwise, you would not engage in such a disproportionate Katju-Bhakti like you seem to be doing now! I suggest that you should start reading newspapers and watch TV news and debates instead of the Daily Saas-Bhu Sob Operas that you are so much used to watching. Once you follow my advice you won't need any Katju to tell you what the world already knows enough of and thereafter you will stop worshiping ordinary mortals like Mr. katju.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-27366687174733408372014-08-12T11:26:08.325+05:302014-08-12T11:26:08.325+05:30Apriya Satyam na bruyat...Apriya Satyam na bruyat...Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1720071062570496465.post-20232347225495070242014-08-12T06:50:17.989+05:302014-08-12T06:50:17.989+05:30Omprakash: Very valid points. I don't know his...Omprakash: Very valid points. I don't know history behind impeachment process how it got into the system. May have come from British laws. You are right. The nation has to wake up. Lower court judiciary appointments cannot happen in dark. People should demand transparency in such appointments. Its not the ruling party to decide how judicial vacancies are filled. In Tamil Nadu, I was told that it goes to highest bidder. Time that young people take up this cause. Murthy S. Inquisitive Economisthttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00445173308747091977noreply@blogger.com