' Netaji ' Subhas Chandra Bose
If ' Netaji ' was not a Japanese agent, why did he surrender when the Japanese surrendered ? He should have carried on a guerilla war against the British.
If the Japanese had been victorious against the British do you seriously think they would have granted independence to India ? No, they would have made India a Japanese colony, and ruthlessly exploited and looted it.
In fact Bose was being used by the Japanese, and they would have bumped him off the moment his utility for them was over. He was no doubt a brave and personally honest man, but he had become an agent of Japanese fascism
If ' Netaji ' was not a Japanese agent, why did he surrender when the Japanese surrendered ? He should have carried on a guerilla war against the British.
If the Japanese had been victorious against the British do you seriously think they would have granted independence to India ? No, they would have made India a Japanese colony, and ruthlessly exploited and looted it.
In fact Bose was being used by the Japanese, and they would have bumped him off the moment his utility for them was over. He was no doubt a brave and personally honest man, but he had become an agent of Japanese fascism
vry well said sirji ...
ReplyDeleteSir,
ReplyDeleteNetaji was a brave & honest man, but somewhere the Japs fooled him & yes the Japanese would have dumped him, had they succeeded in their plans. May be the situation then could have been even more worse, like what Japanese did in China & korea.
Some more info. here :
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/08/netaji-subhash-chandra-bose-untold.html
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2012/07/unsung-heroes-of-ina-capt-ajit-vadakayil.html
Thanks.
I disagree about what you think of Netaji. When Japan decided to surrender Netaji refused to let himself in. So Japanese allowed him to go elsewhere. Ami sub hash bolchi a book written by sailesh dey had dealt this in detail. We presume that Netaji was captured later by Indian police at the behast of Nehru,ballabhai Patel and Gandhi. He was handed over to Russia and finally landed in a jail in England where he was hanged. RTI act failed to bring the papers out and Mr. Pronob Mukherjee went into record by telling disclosures will strain international relation with many friendly countries. So Netaji never surrendered he went in search of another way to attack the British.
ReplyDeleteexactly Netaji never surrendered . he wanted to reorganise his efforts but he fell victim to a larger conspiracy and sadly the certain indian leaders were in collusion with foreign powers to cause his mysterious death . politicsathighandlow.blogspot.com
DeleteAnd the writer is not a fool who thinks a person who can go this far for his country has not a slightest idea about what japanies can do or could do.
ReplyDeleteyes totally agree, but subhash chndra bose wasnt jap agent,he was a true desh bhakt who was tricked/fooled by the Japs.if japs werent defeated in WW2 undoubteldy india wud have been another colony of japan.japanese were planning to wipe out indian population using bio-weapons.
ReplyDeletesubhash chandra bose wasnt good at geopolitics, and fell in japanese trap.
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/08/netaji-subhash-chandra-bose-untold.html
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.com/2012/10/doctor-death-shiro-ishii-emperor.html
Sir.. why all about the past... do you live in present or not?
ReplyDeletemany people follow you, for maybe chaaploosi or anything, praising your posts for reasons they best know. But its my sincere request to consider the present society and clean it up rather then taking up issues of past...
why crime against women is increasing and what to do when law stopping crime against women is misused by women for extortion?
demand of dowry has killed many girls, but hasn't laws like 498A killed anyone yet?
did you do anything in your lifetime and during your tenure as Justice to curb crime and misuse of law altogether? If yes (as i expect the reply to be), kindly show the results.
Knowing your past is necessary to build a strong future !!
DeleteRIGHT MULA HASBARA........
DeleteDonot call him sir, he is a cheap ass.
DeleteDonot call him sir, he is a cheap ass.
DeleteSir... one fresh question please... try and reply...
ReplyDeletewhy justices of courts from district court to Hon'ble Supreme Court are appointed to another department after they are retired? They get pension and salary from other department as well, while young generation sits unemployed.
one expected answer: committees and tribunals etc. require experienced person to truly achieve the ends of justice
further question: why judges are not transferred while they are serving in tenure? this would make their seats empty, lower judges getting promotions, and lowest seats getting vacant... offering more employments..
did you do anything in this regard?.. oh.. sorry.. you yourself are former Chairman, Press Council of India,...
what patriotism... cursing Gandhi ji, a self-less person..... and not leaving any opportunity for fellow citizens to be employed... not all... but atleast you yourself could have left one seat... that would have made you a truly great spirit..
my humble request... stop creating controversies on those great spirits... we can not do anything they did in their lifetime..
Hey Sunil,
DeleteYeah we cannot do anything about what they did in their lives, but we can for sure stop giving them unwanted, god like treatment. This will force the Dark forces to think twice before propping up a Gandhi-II ( possible nominees for Gandhi II already in que are Anna hazare, kailash satyarthi.)
I believe India would have got Independence much earlier had Gandhi not returned back to India & fought with so called Non Violence.
And why are you so eager to cover the Man who recruited 13 lakh Indians to fight for British in WW-1 (out of this 1.11 lakh lost their lives fighting for Gora's), and 25 lakh Indians to fight for them in WW2 (out of which 2.43 lakh died).
Doesn't your heart pain for those innocent Indian soldiers whom the Greatest believer of NON VIOLENCE THE MAHATAMA GANDHI duped to fight for BRITISH RAJ.
I most humbly request you, if you are a true Desh Bhakt, don't advocate Gandhi. Stop giving excuses to cover up his dead A#s. If not tell in what way you are connected to Gandhi Family, as now I can smell a rat.
yeah.. like India achieved it in 1857.. the biggest revolt of the Indian History... Correct your history first sir.. Indians didn't win freedom by war... but in exchange of promise which britishers made with Gandhi, during WWII.
DeleteGandhi ji belonged to Harijan/Dalit family.. I being Sharma can't be connected to them in any manner whatsoever.. But its me, a Sharma, how feels Gandhi his GURU... doesn't it show that India has grown over caste-system?
before writing any further on contribution of Gandhi Ji to Indian freedom... please correct your history, and let me know where did we fight and won our independence...
Bhagat Singh, a great soul... was killed like nothing, and if Gandhi agreed to Bhagat's thought, many more would have been... Gandhi Ji took his movement back, after incident of choura-chauri only... knowing what britisher forces can do to our civilians fighting with a lathi only...
Before criticising a dead person and his contribution... do you feel you have done anything over and above that man?... I am fighting against open availability of porn (without notice of media), fighting against misuse of laws like 498A (no media attention), fighting against corrupt police system (nothing again).. because like Gandhi Ji, even I don't have any political agendas... that's why I call him my GURU... who would always be... The very FIRST LAW PERSON of India....
Ask mr. katju, if he so hates britishers and their links with Gandhi, where in his lifetime he has appealed Indian Govt. to make their own laws now, after we are Independent since long. ... almost each and every law we are governed by is made by Britishers...
Britishers were never bad law makers... they were just targetted by our Political leaders for their interests.. so they enjoy with the name of Congress (which is in no way connected to Gandhi)... Gandhi wanted co-operation... see portugal and australia... and see India... you'll see what your own did to you and what britishers did for others...
Still I believe in Independence... But Gandhi ji was right... India is not ready for Independence... see... more then 65 years... we're governed by IPC, CPC, Contract Act and many more basic laws, which are made at the time of britishers and by britishers...
Thank you HISTORY READERS...
I guess Mr. katju has lost, what all persons lose after retirement.. so to be called RETIRED... and I won't throw a stone again on him now... my guru said "AN EYE FOR AN EYE, AND THE WORLD WILL BE BLIND"..
DeleteThank you Mr. Katju, for your great not-known contributions to system/legal/administrative reforms, which despite being your duty and within your power, you DID and we are living in a safe society now after you are retired... ..
http://justicekatju.blogspot.in/2015/03/netaji-subhas-chandra-bose-if-netaji.html#comment-form
ReplyDeleteKATJU SAAB-
JAPANESE FOOLED BOSE .
INA SOLDIERS WERE USED BY THE JAPS TO DIG MORE THAN 600 KMS OF TUNNELS THROUGH PUMICE ROCK AT RABAUL ISLAND .
AFTER THAT , 22,000 INA SOLDIERS WERE EATEN BY JAPS FOR DINNER .
CHURCHILL HAS HIS REVENGE BY STARVING 5.2 MILLION BENGALIS TO DEATH - JUST BECAUSE BOSE WAS A BENGALI .
AMARTYA SEN WHO WHITEWASHED CHURCHILLs GENOCIDE WAS GIVEN A NOBeL PRIZE .
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/09/amartya-sen-gets-nobel-prize-for.html
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/08/netaji-subhash-chandra-bose-untold.html
OUR NCERT TEXT BOOKS CONTAIN R COMMIE LIES .
capt ajit vadakayil
..
The Japanese invasion of Burma was with only 7000 Indian soldiers but 93000 Japs.
DeleteSo, I don't think Netaji Bose was fool enough to think that these handful of soldiers will liberate India and hand over the reigns of the country to INA.
He was always banking on the ranks and file of the British Indian army to revolt against their Masters. As the Naval Mutiny of 1946 proved, this was indeed the case. All the mutineers were found to be members of the CPI of Bengal.
Neta ji Bose was man of high calibre . It is foolish to think that could be fooled by japs . it is true that after initial success of INA the British Indian Army would have revolted in support of Netaji . politicsathighandlow.blogspot.com
DeleteSir,
ReplyDeleteI am not very knowledgeable or anything but just an innocent question. How would a person who is known to have been able to fool the whole of British government and so on and so forth, have not seen or even got an idea of what the Japanese were up to or whether they were using him for their own purposes?
You might be right but the question just popped into my mind and I felt like asking.
sabarish
ReplyDeleteMarch 11, 2015 at 6:46 AM
Guruji..as you had predicted, our FM to unveil Gandhi statue in UK. No other better work?
ReplyDelete
Replies
######################################
Capt. Ajit Vadakayil
March 11, 2015 at 7:23 AM
hi s,
R IS MORE INTERESTED IN KEEPING GANDHI ALIVE IN THE MINDS OF INDIAS.
EVERY PERSON WHO COMES ON PRIME TIME TV AND KEEPS PRAISING GANDHI-DOES SO FOR A REASON .
IN USA -- THEY PRAISE MARTIN LUTHER KING JR --WHO TOLD THE BLACKS TO ALLOW THE WHITES TO SHIT ON THEIR FACES.
ALL TV CHANNELS BLANKED OUT WHAT KATJU TOLD -- THAT GANDHI IS A BRITISH AGENT .
KATJU IS NOT SMALL FRY-- HE IS EX-CJI AND EX- PRESS COUNCIL CHAIRMAN.
THEY ARE ALL BUSY DESCRIBING SHIKAR DHAWANs CENTURY AGAINST MINNOWS IRELAND.
THE BENAMI MEDIA LITERALLY BRANDED HIM MAD -- " KATJU AT IT AGAIN " "HERE IS A NEW ONE FROM KATJU " TYPE SLIMY INNUENDO .
THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF HASBARAS OPERATING ON INDIAN SOCIAL MEDIA .
THIS IS IN THE MOSSAD BLUE BOOK-- DECLARE SOMEONE WHO TELLS THE TRUTH--AS MAD.
when hilter's NO 2 RULDOPH HESS airdropped into britain to stop world war 2-- churchill promptly declared him mad.
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/11/rudolf-hess-honourable-man-who-was.html
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2013/10/hasbara-jewish-propaganda-on-social.html
capt ajit vadakayil
..
sabarish
ReplyDeleteMarch 11, 2015 at 6:46 AM
Guruji..as you had predicted, our FM to unveil Gandhi statue in UK. No other better work?
ReplyDelete
Replies
######################################
Capt. Ajit Vadakayil
March 11, 2015 at 7:23 AM
hi s,
R IS MORE INTERESTED IN KEEPING GANDHI ALIVE IN THE MINDS OF INDIAS.
EVERY PERSON WHO COMES ON PRIME TIME TV AND KEEPS PRAISING GANDHI-DOES SO FOR A REASON .
IN USA -- THEY PRAISE MARTIN LUTHER KING JR --WHO TOLD THE BLACKS TO ALLOW THE WHITES TO SHIT ON THEIR FACES.
ALL TV CHANNELS BLANKED OUT WHAT KATJU TOLD -- THAT GANDHI IS A BRITISH AGENT .
KATJU IS NOT SMALL FRY-- HE IS EX-CJI AND EX- PRESS COUNCIL CHAIRMAN.
THEY ARE ALL BUSY DESCRIBING SHIKAR DHAWANs CENTURY AGAINST MINNOWS IRELAND.
THE BENAMI MEDIA LITERALLY BRANDED HIM MAD -- " KATJU AT IT AGAIN " "HERE IS A NEW ONE FROM KATJU " TYPE SLIMY INNUENDO .
THERE ARE HUNDREDS OF HASBARAS OPERATING ON INDIAN SOCIAL MEDIA .
THIS IS IN THE MOSSAD BLUE BOOK-- DECLARE SOMEONE WHO TELLS THE TRUTH--AS MAD.
when hilter's NO 2 RULDOPH HESS airdropped into britain to stop world war 2-- churchill promptly declared him mad.
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/11/rudolf-hess-honourable-man-who-was.html
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2013/10/hasbara-jewish-propaganda-on-social.html
capt ajit vadakayil
..
Katju sir, there is a mistake in the last line of this very blog.
ReplyDeleteInstead of
"...he had become an agent of Japanese fascism." it should be like
"...he had become an victim of Japanese fascism"
Dear Mr. Katju,
ReplyDeleteAll India Forward Bloc condemn the statement about Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and Gandhiji in your blog where you have written Gandhi as a British Agent and Netaji Subhas as a Japanese Agent, we believe that only an anti nation people can utter this type words about them.
Aside we also believe that in this age, specially after retirement from Supreme Court and Press Council of India you may not be in stable physical and mental condition. We have already requested to all supporters and countrymen to send flowers & pray for your physical and mental recovery. (though you should be punished for this anti nation activity)
Get well soon Mr. Katju. Our sympathy is with you always.
Sir, about Shubhas ji we can say he was not power hungry , is only mission was freedom for our country. And after getting freedom , he remain annoymous like hitler in hideout. Hope u can understand. He was very intelligent and knew what things will conspire after world war. When mission is accomplised and goal achived.......then nothing matters..................we intelligent must not use ifs and buts
ReplyDeleteI disagree with Justice Markandey Katju .."That Subhash Chandra Bose was an agent of Japanese imperialism". Actually Bose was more an agent of Aryan Supremacist Hitler's regime.
ReplyDeleteSIR..I too can't grasp it on the basis of my understanding ....
ReplyDeletesir,...what were causes of rifts and mismatches between Gandhi and Gandhi? why did he leave India ? Were there any authentic reasons ?
ReplyDeletehttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Sharad-Yadav-continues-sexist-remarks-tells-Smriti-Irani-I-know-what-you-are/articleshow/46585284.cms
ReplyDeleteSUBJECT : Sharad Yadav continues sexist remarks, tells Smriti Irani: 'I know what you are'
#########################################
IN THE PAST ONE YEAR 95% OF THE TIME OCCUPIED BY PILLARS OF MEDIA ( BENAMI MAIN STREAM ) AND LEGISLATURE ( RAJYA SABHA ) IS FOR MATTERS WHICH DIVIDE AND DESTROY INDIA . . .
HARDLY ANYTIME IS SPENT ON NATION BUILDING.
THE CULPRITS CAN EASILY BE IDENTIFIED- AS THEY ARE CONTROLLED BY FOREIGN FORCES WHO ARE JEALOUS OF INDIAs PROGRESS . . . .
THE WHITE NATIONS DO NOT WANT YELLOW CHINA AND BROWN INDIA TO OVERTAKE THEM AND BECOME THE PLANETS NO 1 AND 2 SUPERPOWERS . . .
THESE WHITE ZIONIST NATIONS CONTROL THEIR TROJAN HORSE NGOs IN INDIA . . .
EVERY DAY THE BENAMI MAIN STREAM MEDIA TALKS ABOUT GANG RAPE-- WHICH IS A LIE . .
INDIA HAS 1260 MILLION PEOPLE--
OUR RAPE BY PERCENTAGE ( NOT NUMBERS ) IS THE LOWEST ON THE PLANET .
OUR INDIAN WOMEN ARE THE MOST RESPECTED AND SAFEST ON THE PLANET - I HAVE TRAVELLED FOR 4 DECADES AND I KNOW . .- UNLIKE OTHERS WHO DEPEND ON WHITE MANs LIES IN MEDIA . . . .
INDIA HAS THE LOWEST RAPE/ DIVORCE/ VIOLENT CRIME/ INCARCERATION / HOMOSEXUAL PERCENTAGE ON THE PLANET . . .
NUMBERS ARE IRRELEVANT - ONLY PERCENTAGE MATTERS. . . .
THE WEST IS JEALOUS OF THE HAPPINESS / HARMONY IN INDIAN HOMES . . .
TO BREAK INDIA THE ZIONISTS MUST FIRST BREAK OUR SOCIAL FABRIC -
THIS IS WHAT THEY ARE TRYING , USING THEIR BENAMI MEDIA AND JUDAS POLITICIANS IN THEIR PAYROLL IN INDIAN PARLIAMENT . . .
IN 20 YEARS INDIA WILL BECOME THE PLANETS NO 1 SUPERPOWER .
THE BROWN MAN MUST FORGET THE LEGACY OF GANDHI . . .
THE BLACK MAN MUST FORGET THE LEGACY OF MARTIN LUTHER KING JR .
BOTH THESE MEN CREATED AND ELIMINATED BY THE SAME BIG BROTHER TOLD THEIR ENSLAVED PEOPLE TO LOVE THE WHITE AGGRESSORS WHO OPPRESSED THEM . . .
THE FREE WORLD HAS WOKEN UP . . . THANKS GOD PUTIN LEADS US WITH BRICS . . .
punch into Google search - -
. . . . VLADIMIR PUTIN THE HERO OF THE FREE WORLD VADAKAYIL . . .
capt ajit vadakayil
..
http://justicekatju.blogspot.in/2015/03/alice-in-wonderland-both-houses-of.html?showComment=1426721982522#c7583204111906289172
ReplyDeleteBOSE WAS FOOLED BY THE JAPANESE . .
THEY MADE HIS INA SOLDIERS , 22000 OF THEM, DIG MORE THAN 620 KM OF TUNNELS TROUGH HARD PUMICE ROCK --AND THEN ATE THEM FOR DINNER . .
THEY HAD A HUMAN MEAT CANNING FACTORY INSIDE THE TUNNELS . . .
This Japanese Rabaul Island base was never taken by allies , as they were too well entrenched thanks to this amazing tunnel maze.
Though they had more than 120000 Japanese soldiers there, they wanted SLAVE LABOUR to cut deep tunnels in volcanic Pumice rock.
The temperatures in the tunnel would be 45 deg C and humid. They figured only the tropical Indian could do it, in a docile manner--especially if they are fooled into thinking it is a war effort.
Once the terrible digging job started all such pretenses stopped.
Once the terrible digging job started all such pretenses stopped.
The locals there were hardly 3500 in number, and were proper Papua New Guinea cannibals, who would eat you up if they got a chance.
Out of the 130000 prisoners at Changi Singapore - 41000 were Indian soldiers. Out of this more than half of this formed INA Indian soldiers’ battalion were tricked to ostensibly fight shoulder to shoulder against the British in other fronts and taken by ship and secretly dumped in Rabaul.
ALL THIS WAS HIDDEN , TILL I POSTED MY BLOG BELOW . . .BASED ON DIRECT INFORMATION FROM THE ISLAND CHIEFs SON . .
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/08/netaji-subhash-chandra-bose-untold.html
They had 2200 prostitutes shipped in from China, Phillipines and Korea. All of them lived in the tunnels.
There was NO electricity to have power tools. Over the last 9 months , to keep at least one air strip operational the Indians were forced to work in the open even with bombs falling around them.
It must be understood that Americans dropped 20967 tons of bombs on Rabaul in 29354 sorties .
It had everything built into it, including a 2500 bed hospital , four kilometers long , with five basement levels .
WHY IS THE INDIAN GOVT HIDING TRUE HISTORY ?
WHO GAINS ?
capt ajit vadakayil
..
ReplyDeleteSTOP PRESS:
the white invader have shown us FAKE sanskrit verses and poison injected history to prove that--
shiva eats dead men in the cremation grounds
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/09/aghoris-corpse-eaters-of-india-capt.html
our ancient queens fornicated with the dead horse's prick after the ashwamedha yagna
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/09/ashwamedha-yagam-bloodless-sacrifice.html
that our temples did human / animal sacrifice
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/11/all-animal-sacrifices-in-hindu-temples.html
that our devadasis were whores who serviced pujaris and devotees coming to the temple
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/02/devadasi-system-immoral-lie-of-temple.html
that kamasutra was all about deviant sex
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/07/kamasutra-by-vatsayana-immoral-sexual.html
that maharishi manu was world's no 1 racist
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2012/08/cnn-ibn-poll-greatest-indian-since.html
that hindus sexually abused the devi goddess so that she gets angry and develops more powers.
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2013/03/kodungallur-bharani-festival-capt-ajit.html
that gandhi charkha ghumaake humko aazadi dilwaya
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2012/09/mahatma-gandhi-re-writing-indian.html
that krishna had a mistress outside marriage named radha
that krishna was a sex maniac who screwed 16000 bhargen - nay - virgin damsels
that rama was a cruel and paranaoid man who kicked his pregnant wife into the forest
that shiva was a chakka transgender
that shiva was a sexual pervert who walked around deodhar forest with an erect prick
that the wives of saptarishis ( gotra ) screwed around with shiva
that brahma/ vishnu/ shiva held competitions and cheated each other to show who is stronger .
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2013/05/dvaita-vedanta-of-sanatana-dharma-or.html
that england was a bigger country than india
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/01/country-size-racist-conspiracy-capt.html
that shiva lingam was a stone prick inserted into a yoni vagina
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2012/05/lord-shiva-shivalingam-dance-of-shiva.html
that hindusim is a very recent religion
that hindus worshipped 330 million ridiculous deities
that so many back dated DASAS , mutts and reformers tried to uplift the evil thinking hindus
that all ancient scripture stalwarts were evil people
that evil mind of chanakya represented the evil and slimy hindu
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/08/chanakya-taxila-university-professor.html
hindusim created the evil swastika symbol
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/02/swastika-symbol-capt-ajit-vadakayil.html
that the star of david is the jewish symbol - shiva - shakti merging triangles
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/07/saundarya-lahari-by-adi-shankaracharya.html
that stupid indians thought world is flat and sun goes around earth - when aryabhatta wrote it is round and earth goes around sun in 2700 BC
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2012/06/heliocentricity-versus-geocentricity.html
that ganges water is dirty water which gives cholera and typhoid
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/06/ganga-manthan-cleaning-of-river-ganges.html
that saraswati river and ancient saraswati civilization never existed
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/01/mother-of-all-civilisations-saraswati.html
that OM was to call cows -while they lifted SHALOM and AMEN
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2011/07/om-aum-sound-of-zpf-cymatics-sound-of.html
that indians had no inventions / discoveries till the white man invaded-while actually it was the other way around.
http://ajitvadakayil.blogspot.in/2014/12/we-are-hindus-we-are-indians-we-are.html
CONTINUED TO 2-
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDear Justice Katju,
ReplyDeleteWe respect you a lot and read your posts regularly. Most often we agree with your razor sharp opinions and feel you're giving words to the many suppressed minds. But this time we want to disagree with your opinion on Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, who is a hero to many.
We want to be least opinionated here, yet want to present few facts chronologically, as we know (we're not historians so if there are some mistakes, please correct us)
1. He was Congress President during 1938 and 1939, though had to leave from Congress leadership positions in 1939 following differences with Gandhi.
(He looked for a new avenue to serve the country after that "not so easily acceptable experience by many". He didn't put his ego before country, did he?)
2. He was subsequently placed under house arrest by the British before escaping from India in 1940.
(That proves he wasn't a British agent either.)
3. He escaped and went to Germany in April 1941, where the leadership offered unexpected, if sometimes ambivalent, sympathy for the cause of India's independence.
(Is it asylum seeking? Even if one may think so at this stage, it is Germany and not Japan)
4. In November 1941, with German funds, a Free India Centre was set up in Berlin, and soon a Free India Radio.
(Again in Germany and utilizing German fund for the cause of his own Country. No Japan yet. But this shows he was ready to accept any help (may be at any cost) to serve India and the freedom)
5. In 1942, Free India Legion, intended to serve as a liberation force for India was formed by him.
(Showed his intent on gathering army to get into war against British. Though an obvious "David vs Goliath" dream, but he he was seeking strong partners too. No clear intention of getting into Guerrilla war strategy, to note he was outside India at that time, which is not a best way to adopt Guerrilla war strategy)
6. Bose had a meeting wit Hitler in late May 1942, when he was suggested to sought help from Japan, in light of Japanese victories in southeast Asia at that time.
(Idea of Japan as ally got a push in his mind)
7. Bose boarded a German submarine in February 1943, subsequently he was transferred to a Japanese submarine from which he disembarked in Japanese land in May 1943.
(Now he is in Japan, with already set mind of what he wants. Can we say "on a mission"?)
8. With Japanese support, he revamped the Indian National Army, whose contribution to the India's freedom can hardly be undermined.
(We think, INA most likely was one important wake up call for the British rulers)
9. Unfortunately his military effort was short lived and lost steam by late 1944 and early 1945. He chose not to surrender while Japanese did, but rather tried to escape seeking a future in the Soviet Union which he believed to be turning anti-British.
(By this time, he was still jumping wagons with only one motto, to gather enough force to overthrow British from India)
10. We hardly know for sure what have happened to him and where after that.
So, can one really paint him as Japanese Agent? Looking ahead to read your detailed analysis and reasoning.
Netaji was a practicing and very believing Hindu but in his political life he was demonstrably secular.
ReplyDeleteTo quote from Modern India by Sumit Sarkar :
"The I.N.A. was demonstratively non-communal, with
Muslims quite prominent among its officers and ranks, and it also introduced the innovation of a
women's detachment named after the Rani of Jhansi. Between March and June 1944, the I.N.A.
was in action on Indian soil, beseiging Imphal along with Japanese troops in a campaign which
ended in total failure. The Japanese collapse in the next year made the I.N.A. men prisoners
again, while Bose mysteriously disappeared, allegedly killed in an air-crash which some still
believe to have been faked.
In assessing the significance of the last phase of Subhas Bose's career, it is important to
distinguish between immediate achievement and ultimate (and mainly psychological) impact.
The I.N.A. never amounted to very much in sheer military terms, and even if it had been far
more effective, it obviously came too late, for everywhere the Axis powers were in retreat by
1944. The Forward Bloc underground in India, which might have backed up the Imphal-Kohima
invasion, had been crushed even earlier (Secretary of State's memorandum on the Forward Bloc,
30 August 1945, Mansergh, Vol. VI, pp. 183-88). Yet we must not underestimate the impact on
the patriotic imagination of an actual army fighting, however ineffectively, for the country's
liberation, led by a Bengali—the least 'martial' of India's 'races' in traditional British stereotype.
In November 1945, a British move to put the I.N.A. men on trial immediately sparked off
massive demonstrations all over the country. Even more significant was the probable link
between the I.N.A. experience and the wave of disaffection in the British Indian army during the
winter of 1945-46, which culminated in the great Bombay naval strike of February 1946 and was
quite possibly the single most decisive reason behind the British decision to make a quick
withdrawal."
Declassification of files may prove that JAPAN AND BRITISH JOINTLY PLAYED A FOUL GAME WITH NETAJI; In WW-I, Japan was a British ally. Before WW-II, Japan-US trade war and
Deletepolitical war started, this led to actual war between US and Japan. So British became an enemy to Japan by diplomatic manipulation as US - British alliance was there. After WW-II, Japan revived their old connection with British. Japanese and British spies were enough linked before WW-II. JAPANESE SPIES AGREED TO ELIMINATE NETAJI. Motive was to appease British and purchase security for Japan royal family. So, JAPAN HANDED OVER NETAJI TO BRITISH AND BRITISH EXECUTED HIM IN SECRETE. The false news of air crash was fabrication of Japan. In any controversial case, liar is to be suspected first.
Netaji plan to start second independence war with USSR help was known to Japan. There was enough scope for British and Japanese spies to develop a common minimum program against pro-communist agenda of Netaji. Why should Japanese imperialism agree to patronize emergence of independent India as a permanent communist ally? Is it not more logical to fulfill British condition and purchase favor? Why Japan royal family was not tried as a war criminal? What is the mystery behind this favor?
There is another point about gumnami baba. Who was he? Gumnami baba was a dummy created as a part of common minimum program of Japanese imperialism and British imperialism. In axis camp, creation of dummy by plastic surgery was a common practice. Hitler and Mussolini were having number of dummies. Japan sold Netaji-dummy to British. British deputed this dummy at faizabad of UP, with a purpose to create confusion that as if death or life Netaji is doubtful. The confusion prevented the nation to be doubtful about role of Japan or British. So gumnami baba of faizabad is a common creation of Japanese spies and British spies. Never had he told the truth. If he had told anything, that must be lie. In a controversial case, liar is to be suspected. So, JAPAN SOLD NETAJI TO BRITISH AND BRITISH EXECUTED HIM IN SECRET. Japan sold Netaji-dummy to British and British deputed him at faizabad of Uttar-Pradesh. JAPAN SURRENDERED TO US-UK SIDE ON 15TH AUGUST 1945. Netaji’s last flight was on 18th august 1945. A SURRENDERED JAPAN WAS NO LONGER AN ALLY OF AZAD HIND. They worked as per their new mentors, the British.